No, we don’t
really want to give him too much attention ... Nick Fuentes is a shitpost troll
– indeed, Nick Fuentes is something close to a Platonic idea of a shitpost
troll, and paying him attention is probably exactly the wrong thing to do. On
the other hand, Fuentes is a symptom of a certain current – the
boogaloo, groyper post-truth shitposting culture –
in modern society that is both hard and dangerous to overlook: Fuentes, who is
the de facto leader of the Groyper Army, is explicitly campaigning to move
the overton window (“I wanna be the furthest Right reactionary and
drag everybody over”, says Fuentes
) in order to normalize the erratic, pseudofascist
behavior of the MAGA crowds (and to mainstream brazen white supremacism and
anti-semitism), and does so by performing militant ideological extremism and
utter nihilism at the same time; Fuentes is the bastard fascist offspring of
(good and proper) GenX irony and naïve Millenial sincerity, nurtured by the
fear, hate and paranoia of various far-right factions (religious right,
conspiracy groups, nativists) to serve as a beacon luring these groups to the
altright by explicitly formulating the
ideas the groups were attracted to but remained reluctant to entertain. It is unclear, however, whether Fuentes’s
ultimate goal is – if anything at all – anything other than to burn it all
down, but that goal is apparently appealing to many religious fundies and
wingnut conspiracy theorists. You can read a basic portrait of Nick Fuentes
here: https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Nick_Fuentes and a more comprehensive one here, though this one is probably even more illuminating
when it comes to Fuentes’s role and position on the right.
In any
case, Nicholas Joseph Fuentes presents as an alt-right radical-traditionalist
Catholic white supremacist neo-Nazi and self-described incel, and he operates the America First
livestream podcast, hosted by his own proprietary website after having been
banned from most mainstream channels like youtube. He previously co-hosted the
Nationalist Review podcast with fellow neo-Nazi James Allsup.
Some
professed views
At the core of Fuentes’s persona is a deepseated frustration
at what he believes is the end of America, expressed as hate against any trait,
tendency, group or idea that he could perceive (or pretend to perceive) as
being a part of a cause of its decline – and since he is rarely clear about
what properties of past America he favors, any agent of change or
non-change for anything at any level is a target. This includes not only
Muslims (“[t]he First Amendment was not written for Muslims”,
nor for “immigrants”), liberals, feminists and people of color, but any non-Catholic
(“I want this country to have Catholic media, Catholic Hollywood, Catholic
government. I want this to be a Catholic occupied government”) – Fuentes has indeed advocated for “the death penalty”
for all non-Christians, and has repeatedly called for the murder of a large
range of people, in particular
“globalists” and “the people behind CNN”.
But his primary
enemy
is of course zeh
Jews,
who control and have ruined everything, including Star Wars.
“Frankly, I’m getting pretty sick of world Jewry running the show,” says
Fuentes, and frequently emphasizes that “we need to eradicate Jewish
stranglehold over the United States of America” and that jewish people need
to “die in the holy war”.
Indeed, Fuentes is an unapologetic fan of Adolf Hitler
(“ ‘Hitler was a pedophile and kind of a pagan.’ It’s like, well, he was
also really fucking cool. … This guy’s awesome, this guy’s cool”) and has
called for “total Aryan victory”. He is also a Holocaust denier,
even though he rather explicitly thinks a Holocaust would be a good thing. And
his perception of Hitler is … weird at best: after allegedly seeing a Black man
littering, for instance, Fuentes stated that
“It’s always Black people.
… This is in my neighborhood. I’m supposed to be mad at Hitler? I’m supposed to
be cross with Hitler? I want this guy dead. And I wish Hitler would kill him. I
wish Hitler would have killed him, you know? … That guy should be KILLED! That
guy should be killed for that. That guy should be dragged from his car and
beaten to death by the public. … If I was in a room with Hitler and that guy,
me and Hitler would team up and fuck that guy up! We would kill that guy! … And
we’d high-five at the end”. That’s … not who or what Hitler was.
It is,
perhaps, worth quoting a portion of Fuentes’s response to and interpretation of
a June 2022 Biden speech; as Fuentes saw it, Biden “is saying ‘Look,
I’m the big gay American empire, and I’m gonna kill all the enemies of
liberalism’. That’s what he's saying. Biden is there saying, ‘This is global
homo and I’m the puppet face of it. I’m the puppet face of world Jewry and
global homo and we’re gonna crush all these fascists.’ The whole thing is just
a lie. The whole thing is a sham. Biden is a puppet. The elections are fake.
The social media companies are rigged. The elections are rigged. The news
couldn’t be more Jewed-up; Jewed-up, moneyed-up, corporate, under the thumb of
the Illuminati,
whatever. It’s all real man. The devil is in charge of the world. Satan is in
charge of America. […] Satan runs the Western world. When you talk about the
West, when you talk about democracy, you’re talking about the devil. […] Fuck
democracy. I stand with Jesus Christ.”
Fuentes does claim,
rather adamantly, not to be a white supremacist, however, but rather a “Christian
conservative” (he consider the term ‘white supremacist’ an “anti-white
slur”). But he does think that
Jim Crow “was better for [Black people] too” (note the ‘too’), focuses a
lot on white genocide
and Great Replacement
conspiracy theories (here
is his take on the Great Replacement), subscribes to the view that different
races are not just biologically but spiritually different – he has apparently calculated
his own “spiritual whiteness” to be 91% – and denounces “race-mixing”
because “people should stick with their own kind”.
The rot he claims to have identified in the US has ruined
everything; the military, for instance, has at present degenerated to
become a “mercenary army of N-words and homosexuals” who are being trained “to
obediently murder whites when the time comes”.
He is also proud of being a “sexist man”
of the kind who claims
that “we need to go back to burning women alive more”, and he has advocated
for repealing women’s rights to engage in politics or have a career – indeed,
he has argued that
women should wear veils (he has defended Iran’s hijab rules),
that he “would rather get taken out and shot in the head” than be
treated as a female doctor, that men have the right to beat and rape their
wives because the Bible gives them authority over women (the problem with marriage today is that
women are “not afraid of getting hit, she’s not afraid of being killed,
she’s not afraid of violence”), and that all women will go to Hell. He is
also a self-declared proud incel (which is sort of a contradiction given the
‘in’ part), since
“[i]f we’re really being honest, never having a girlfriend, never having sex
with a woman really makes you more heterosexual because honestly, dating women
is gay. [Men] having sex with women is gay” (his reasoning is related in
more detail here
for anyone interested).
His expressed views on things science are predictable. While
initially supporting the Taliban’s prohibition on vaccines, he did not approve
of their later change of course; Fuentes has referred
to the coronavirus vaccine as “gene therapy” and linked it to the spread
of AIDS. He has also vacillated a bit on his views on dinosaurs, having
advocated both straight-up dino-denialsm
(“I find it had to believe, about the dinosaurs”, and the idea of giant
reptiles is “retarded. … Catholic Groypers are gonna come up, beat the shit
out of you with a Bible”) and human–dinosaur coexistence
(“it’s biblical, bro”).
His views on climate change are in many ways similar; claiming that we’ll never
run out of oil because “oil is infinite” and was put here by God for us
to burn, Fuentes also asserted that
we “need to burn oil so that we can create a stronger atmosphere to keep
carbon inside the atmosphere. This is all scientific.”
In short, the America we according to Nick Fuentes have lost
and that he is yearning for is one that is indistinguishable from ISIS’s
Islamic State beyond some surface nomenclature – indeed Fuentes has explicitly said that
he wishes we had “a Taliban rule in America”. His support for Trump
leading up to 2024 was accordingly
a bit back
and forth,
and he criticized
Trump’s choice of running mate, for instance, because JD Vance “doesn’t
value his racial identity”. When Trump won, Fuentes celebrated that
“there will never, ever be a female president […] Glass ceiling? It’s a
ceiling made of fucking bricks!”, and he was very happy for the actions
taken by Trump and Elon Musk in the immediate wake of the inauguration, since
what they are doing is
“appealing to democracy as a very thin shield for oligarchy” (he’s
sometimes sort of minimally perceptive
on these sorts of things, which suggests that ‘loon’ is not an accurate
epithet)
Activities and fans
Fuentes rose
to prominence on the right after his participation in the alt-right Unite the Right rally in 2017 and would soon appear in
all the places you’d suspect (such as InfoWars). He was of course present in
Washington D.C. on January 6, 2021
– Fuentes declared (while
giving a Nazi salute) that “I am a Trump cultist”
(later:
“Forget the Constitution, I swear allegiance to Donald Trump ... Long live
the rightful king of America”) – and his groyper army quickly became frontplayers
in the subsequent Stop the Steal coalition. In 2022, he was hosted by Trump himself
at a dinner at Mar-a-Lago with Fuentes’s fan and recurring collaborator Kanye West.
Indeed, Fuentes enjoys massive popularity – at the time of
his 2021 Twitter ban (later reinstated), he had more than 125,000 followers,
and the number of fans have grown exponentially since then – and frequently
collaborates with influential wingnut and groyper-adjacent influencers, such as
Pearl
(who felt compelled to denounce him after the first time, claiming ignorance,
but nevertheless continued to work with him afterwards). Fuentes and his
groypers have also managed to largely take over college Republican spaces.
An indication of his popularity might be discerned through
the attention given to his America First Political Action Conference,
established as an alternative to a CPAC,
which is – of course – not extreme enough for Fuentes and his ilk. The purpose of the conference
is to normalize white nationalism, antisemitism and misogyny into the
conservative movement. In addition to Fuentes himself e.g. praising Putin for
his unprompted invasion of the Ukraine (while it was happening in 2022 –
Fuentes has repeatedly praised
“the Russian heroes of the special military operation”) and comparing
Putin to Hitler (intended as praise), the 2022 version of the event attracted
guests like Jared Taylor,
Tim “Baked Alaska” Gionet,
Milo Yiannopoulos,
Gavin McInnes,
Jaden McNeil,
VDARE founder Peter Brimelow,
and long-time Fuentes supporter Michelle Malkin;
and speakers included people like Paul Gosar
(who repeated the America First mantra “America First is inevitable” in
his speech
and who has enjoyed a long but occasionally shaky
relationship with Fuentes, including planning fundraisers with him),
Steve King,
Idaho Lt. Gov Janice McGeachin,
Andrew Torba,
Vincent James Foxx,
Joe Arpaio,
Stew Peters,
Marjorie Taylor Greene,
Laura Loomer
and Arizona state senator Wendy Rogers,
who had earlier, in response to Fuentes’s compliments (any reasonable person
would react to compliments from Fuentes with some serious self evaluation)
tweeted
“Thank you, Nick Fuentes. We love you” and in her speech praised the
groypers for standing up to tyranny, and then advocated for executing her
political opponents. There is a report from the 2024 version here;
though somewhat more sparsely attended, the list of guests and speakers included
natural allies like David Duke,
white supremacist Kevin DeAnna,
Jared Taylor
(again), white supremacist Angelo John Gage (a.k.a. Lucas Gage),
Irish neo-Nazi Keith Woods,
Elijah Schaffer,
Danish antivaccine activist and anti-semitic conspiracy theorist Anastasia Loupis,
wingnut talkshow host Anthony Cumia,
InfoWars
foreign correspondent Dan Lyman, and former Turning Point USA
leaders Evan Kilgore
and Morgan Ariel.
Another Fuentes follower
is Texas GOP ex-politician Jonathan Stickland,
head of the Defend Texas Liberty PAC, a Christian nationalist
group bankrolled by the Dominionist
oil tycoons Tim Dunn and Dan & Farris Wilks; Stickland also owns a consulting firm for wingnut
candidates called Pale Horse Strategies, whose social media coordinator
Ella Maulding has praised Fuentes as “the greatest civil rights leader in history”. Stickland’s Fuentes association
led to some rather tumultuous splits in the Texas GOP, with a large group of them
refusing to disassociate themselves from Defend Texas Liberty (or from antisemitism
for that matter).
In 2022,
Fuentes also launched Cozy TV, a streaming network that would be
explicitly “anti-gay, anti-woman, anti-Black, antisemitic”. It was
quickly joined by several familiar wingnut figures, such as Stop the Steal
organizer Ali Alexander, Laura Loomer (who, by the way, is Jewish,
something that had previously led to some clashes with Fuentes) and Roger Stone with his show The Stone
Zone. Some other declared
supporters and/or close allies (beyond the ones mentioned above) include:
- Canadian
white supremacist Faith Goldy
- “Kent State gun girl” Kaitlin Bennett
- Pizzagate
provocateur-turned conservative commentator Jack Posobiec
- Lauren Witzke,
who has referred to Fuentes
as “our great and merciful leader” (one longs for the days when crackpot
fundies would see Jesus merely in floorboards or pieces of toast, doesn’t one?)
- The
Catholic extremist Church Militant network,
in particular its activist wing, the Resistance network; though the association
has caused some discontent in the ChurchMilitant, leaders like Michael Voris
and Joe Gallagher have vigorously defended the association, and central members
like anti-semitic and white nationalist reporter/producer Joseph Enders (“I
support [Fuentes’s] efforts to put America First”) are committed groypers;
indeed, the groypers have made significant inroads among younger Catholics
in general, and are largely the force behind e.g. the emergence of a slew of
self-declared “Charles Coughlin
Roman Catholics”.
- former
host of BlazeTV’s “The White House Brief” Jon Miller
- MAGA rapper
Bryson Gray,
the originator of the viral anti-Biden “Let’s Go Brandon” song
- professional
rightwing troll Jonathan Lee Riches
- Chris Russo, founder and president of Texans for Strong Borders
- Wade Searle,
Congressman Gosar’s digital director, and though it might be natural to suspect
that Searle has been instrumental in maintaining a connection between Fuentes
and Gosar, Searle was appointed after Gosar’s participation at Fuentes
events
- Unite the Right
organizer Jason Kessler
- Chris
Nelson, leader of the Florida People’s Rights network
- American
Greatness editor Pedro Gonzalez,
who praises the groypers as having “chosen to be guided by a Christianity
hammered free of the dross of the modern world” (Gonzalez isn’t widely
praised for his cognitive capabilities or powers of discernment).
- Much
of the group Young Republicans of Texas,
such as their state level secretary Noah Coffee, President of the Parker County
YR chapter and social media coordinator for the New Future Caucus Konner
Earnest, and unapologetic Adolf Hitler fan Rylie Rae Ferguson
- Michigan
political activist and 2023 St. Clair precinct GOP delegate
Alex Roncelli
- Wrongthink
Primetime show conspiracy theorist Anna Perez
For the
2022 midterms, the groypers felt powerful enough to launch their own political
candidates, including Maryland House of Delegates candidate Shekinah Hollingsworth, West Virginia Congressional
candidate Michael Sisco, and California Congressional
candidate Nick Taurus; they were fortunately not at that
time yet within anything resembling striking distance of success.
Lieutenants
Given the
somewhat loose organizational structure of his groyper army, it is tricky to
distinguish henchmen and fans, but among those you could reasonably be describe
as the former, you’ll find at least (probably, and as per July 2024 –
it’s hard to keep track since internal conflicts keep leading to substantial changes
of guard):
- Dalton Clodfelter
- Rumble content creator, antivaccine
activist and Andrew Tate associate Sneako, who claims to have had more than
a million YouTube followers before his channel there was shut down.
- former
MMA fighter Jake Shields
- white
supremacist Lyndon Perry
- white nationalist Kai Schwemmer
- Social
media performer John Doyle
- January
6 2021 Capitol stormer Christian Secour
- Canadian
rightwing nationalist Tyler Russell
Several
people have come and gone, and many have, over the years, distanced themselves from Fuentes, including Patrick Casey a longtime member and
leader of the neo-Nazi group Identity Evropa and possibly something like a cofounder of the
Groyper army; Jaden McNeil; and Simon Dickerman, who helped build America
First’s online structure (Dickerman described America First as “a homosexual
death cult”). It’s important to note that these people have distanced
themselves from the person Fuentes and his inability to foment a real
political movement, and not from his ideas.
Though he
has been immensely influential, the defections are part of a general indication that Fuentes’s reach has contracted a
bit over the last year or two. That would be because he has become sufficiently
famous that elected politicians, candidates for office and people in power,
like Donald Trump, Paul Gosar and Marjorie Taylor Greene, can no longer pretend
never to have heard about him when confronted with having shared a stage with
him (though Gosar tried for years to promote Fuentes and his antics
under that pretense). It is important to be aware that ignorance was
always pretense here: these people – Trump, Gosar, Greene, and so on – supported and/or hosted Fuentes while being
completely aware who he was and what he was standing for (no one in their right
mind would reasonably suggest for instance that Trump would host a dinner at
Mar-a-Lago with two people, Kanye West and Nick Fuentes, without knowing who
they were); what matters at present is that plausible deniability is
less of an option these days.
Diagnosis:
Yes, he is a shitposting troll and little else. The instructive point is that
Nick Fuentes is, in several ways, one of the most influential and powerful
thinkers on the far right today.