Dingbat
morons in state legislatures is nothing new, and Texas has been riddled with
them for a long time; these days, however, state legislative dingbattery seems
to be a potential pathway to the national political scene. Now, we don’t really
think Robert Lee Hall III, a feeble Tea Party candidate who has been serving in
the Texas state legislature since 2015, is in any way bound for Washington, but
his ideas have travelled. Bob Hall is primarily associated with promotion of
misinformation and debunked conspiracy theories related to COVID-19 and
COVID-19 vaccines during the pandemic, including
pushing the nonsense idea that COVID-19 vaccines skipped
animal testing, and encouraging people to forego the vaccine. Instead of protecting yourself by
taking the vaccine, Hall predictably recommended worthless bullshit such as
hydroxychloroquine.
Indeed,
Hall – who of course has no medical background – introduced a proposal to ban any entity, public or
private, from requiring vaccination of their employees (the proposal would
prohibit “discrimination” based on a person’s vaccine
choices). According to Hall, and
completely contrary to reality, “the mere fact that a person
has not received a specific vaccine does not make them a threat to others’
health and safety”; moreover, “in contrast, vaccines they have elected
not to have may very well be a threat to their own health and safety” – as
Hall, like many other anti-vaccine activists saw it, because he and they are
confused morons, the COVID vaccines were “experimental” treatments. Hall supported his proposal with
testimonies from people like legendary pseudoscientist and quack Ben Edwards.
But Hall
was antivaccine before COVID, too. In 2019, for instance, Hall sponsored Texas Senate Bill 2350 (SB2350), which sought to prohibit the
administration of vaccines that did not meet criteria Hall had copypasted from
various anti-vaccine websites; the bill tried for instance to tell the FDA what
criteria they should use for approving new vaccines, it perpetuated standard antivaccine falsehoods about vaccines potentially causing
cancer and infertility, and it tried to parrot false
antivaccine myths to the effect that vaccines aren’t sufficiently tested for safety. The bill died in committee, but only after it had been widely
championed by various anti-vaccine groups in Texas and beyond.
Part of the
popularity of Hall’s efforts among Texan antivaccine activists was due to the
(alleged) fact that it was (purportedly) “rejecting the federal narrative”
(Davis Taylor of the conspiracy theory hub Tenth Amendment Center). And
indeed, Hall is very much worried about federal narratives and federal other
things: in response to the disastrous winter storm that left millions of Texans
without power or water for days in 2021, for instance, Hall was quick to declare that “the absolute worst [mistake]
that we could make would be to join in with the national grid. That would put
us back underneath federal control. And the last thing we need is additional
federal government messing with Texas.”
In 2021, he tried again, with a bill that “would
require physicians to disclose the excipients contained in a vaccine” in order to scare as many as
possible from getting the vaccine by the familiar antivaccine gambit of listing alien-sounding chemicals (the bill would not
require physicians to mention risks associated with foregoing vaccines). Among the ingredients Hall
mistakenly believes vaccines contain are, in
addition to aluminum and MSG, “fetal parts […] that people for religious reasons might not want to take that vaccine”.
According to Hall, the motivation for the bill was “just a matter of making
an informed consent knowing what is being done to them”; Hall is apparently so practised at
anti-vaccine talking point parroting that he can’t even construct meaningful
sentences, but he does, strikingly and unintentionally, reveal a bit about what
these kinds of people mean by 'informed' (it’s not informed). In his presentation of the bill,
Hall notoriously also kept repeating the myth that vaccine manufacturers have no liability; based on that piece of
misinformation, the extra level of ‘informed consent’ is needed because “we are doing
something so dangerous that the federal government has put up a barrier
relieving the pharmaceuticals and doctors of any responsibility for any adverse
affect [sic].”
For his
efforts on behalf of wingnuttery and conspiracy theories, Hall was invited to
speak at Michael Flynn & Clay Clark’s Reawaken
America Tour. Hall was also a speaker at Richard Mack and the Constitutional Sheriffs and Peace Officers Association’s training event for Texas law
enforcement officials in Houston in February 2021.
Diagnosis: Dingbat
moron with little or no grasp of what goes on in reality, but with strong
feelings about it based on paranoia, fanaticism and conspiracy theories. Still
very dangerous, though.