Monday, May 8, 2017

#1832: Devvy Kidd

Devvy Kidd, a spokesmodel by trade, is a conspiracy theorist of the sort who rails against the New World Order and who has occasionally been given column space at the WND. To give you an idea of the kind of stuff she peddles, here is (a report on) her take on the nefarious Alfalfa club, which apparently is a dark, secretive group whose members include the Bushes, John Kerry, Henry Kissinger, Sandra Day O’Connor (“who, in the infamous Lawrence v Texas sodomy set-up case didn’t deny homosexuality is a voluntarily chosen lifestyle”), Mitt Romney and president Obama – or “the current impostor president, Barry Soetoro, aka Obama;” Kidd is, of course, a birther. Oh, and by the way, apparently Kissinger is a communist agent. No, really. Yes, Kissinger.

Otherwise, Kidd promotes the standard wingnut crazy, only slightly more helplessly than usual. So, when trying to argue that the US was founded as a “Christian nation”, Kidd doesn’t only not hesitate to use fake quotes attributed to Jefferson (many borrowed from pseudohistorian David Barton, of course) – she even shamelessly links to original letters in which those quotes do not appear (don’t expect someone like Kidd to actually read her sources). She can even, as proof, point to Patrick Henry claiming that this “great nation” was founded upon Christianity – in 1765, so Henry, who was anyways opposed to the Constitution, could obviously not have been talking about the US – but of course Henry didn’t say that at all; it’s an infamous fake quote. But according to Kidd anyone “who has done the historical homework knows that America is a Christian nation founded upon Christianity and Christianity alone. Atheists and the American Communist Lawyers Union (ACLU) have done their darndest to convince Americans otherwise with their constant propaganda by using repetition of certain phrases, i.e., ‘separation of church and state,’ a [phrase explicitly used by Jefferson to describe the First Amendment] concept hallucinated up by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1947.” We don’t think Kidd really understands what “doing your homework” means. (According to Kidd, the ACLU is “a communist front organization” – she has exhibited no sign of understanding what communism is, either).


Diagnosis: None too concerned with truth, fact or accuracy. She is not alone.

Saturday, May 6, 2017

#1831: Melba Ketchum

A legend in crank circles, Melba Ketchum, a veterinarian by trade, is probably today’s leading, uh, expert on Bigfoot. Ketchum claims to have sequenced Bigfoot DNA and found it to be a new species of hominid that is a hybrid of Homo sapiens and some other species. Yes: Bigfoot arose some 15,000 years ago when some cryptids had sex with modern human females, resulting in hairy hominin hybrids. According to a 2012 press release, which described their five-year long DNA study “currently under peer-review”, Ketchum and her team obtained three “whole nuclear genomes from purported Sasquatch samples. The genome sequencing shows that Sasquatch mtDNA is identical to modern Homo sapiens, but Sasquatch nuDNA is a novel, unknown hominin related to Homo sapiens and other primate species.” Of course, the obvious conclusion to draw (further reasons here) from sequencing showing that Sasquatch mtDNA is identical to modern Homo sapiens, is that her samples were human DNA, but “obvious” is just a repressive tactic of the establishment.

It is also unclear how they determined that the samples were really from a Bigfoot: If they took a blood or saliva sample from a living Bigfoot one may wonder why they didn’t capture or photograph it; if the samples were just found, it is a bit unclear how do they determined that they weren’t left by another animal or hiker. At least Ketchum has (on a different occasion) claimed to have obtained her DNA samples from a blueberry bagel left in the backyard of a Michigan woman who claims that 10 Sasquatch creatures visit her property on a regular basis. Here’s a video recording they made of the beast. Isn’t it unfortunate that it just happens to be so out-of-focus?

It is, however, telling that Ketchum refused to let anyone else see her evidence. She did, however, release a statement requesting that the U.S. government immediately recognize Bigfoot as “an indigenous people and immediately protect their human and Constitutional rights.”

When the paper predictably failed to clear peer review, Ketchum responded by buying an existing journal, renaming it (De Novo) and releasing a special edition containing one paper: her own. According to Ketchum, the standard venues used peer-reviewers that were too close-minded (“I am calling it the ‘Galileo Effect’,” said Ketchum), and “Denovo, the new journal is aimed at offering not only more choices and better service to scientists wanting to submit a manuscript, but also reviewers and editors that will be fair, unlike the treatment we have received.” At least she can now claim to have the results published in a peer-reviewed journal, and that’s what matters. The paper is discussed here; some comments from geneticists are here.

Ketchum is at present still running the Sasquatch genome project, which at the very least sports an awfully formatted webpage. It should probably be a cause of some concern that Ketchum, in her bio, states that she “provides professional forensic consultation and testimony in legal cases.” It would be a pity not to use the skills and techniques acquired from sequencing a Sasquatch genome for public good, such as sending people to jail.

Her team, listed here for future reference, consists of:

-       Patrick Wojkiewicz, “Director of the Shreveport Laboratory of the North Louisiana Crime Lab System and the Technical Leader of the DNA section.”
-       Aliece Watts, “Quality Director for Integrated Forensic Laboratories, Inc.”
-       David W. Spence, “trace evidence supervisor with the Southwestern Institute of Forensic Sciences, Criminal Investigations Laboratory, at Dallas County.”
-       Andreas Holzenburg, Director of the Microscopy & Imaging Center at Texas A&M University.
-       Douglas Toler, “clinical pathologist at Huguley Memorial Hospital in Fort Worth.”
-       Tom Prychitko, “laboratory director at Helix Biological Laboratory, a biological testing firm he established in 2009,” and who apparently has a long backstory of Sasquatch hunting and DNA testing.
-       Fan Zhang, “Bioinformatician at the Department of Academic and Institutional Resources and Technology, University of North Texas Health Science Center.”
-       Ray Shoulders and Ryan Smith (no biographical information given).


Diagnosis: A prime example of how cargo cult science operates, complete with vanity labs and vanity journals. Of course, Ketchum and her gang are mostly pretty harmless and fun, but other pseudoscientists in other fields using the same sorts of approaches and techniques are not.

Friday, May 5, 2017

#1830: Paul Kersey (pseudonym)

Paul Kersey is the pseudonym for the white nationalist and conspiracy theorist who runs the blog Stuff Black People Don’t Like, where he advocates for racial separation. The name “Paul Kersey” is of course borrowed from Charles Bronson’s character in the Death Wish series. We are not going to speculate about the author’s real name.

Kersey seems to have gained a bit of a name for himself in altright circles. For the 2016 election he was a giddy supporter of Donald Trump, saying of his immigration speech that it “was a complete repudiation of ‘The New Colossus’ that was regrettably placed on the Statue of Liberty in 1903,” referring to the Emma Lazarus poem welcoming “your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.” Outside of the altright movement Kersey is probably most famous for claiming that the Oklahoma City bombing was a false flag operation to smear the militia and the anti-immigrant movement.


Diagnosis: Insane, mush-headed racist and bigot. Probably only moderately influential, but there are many of these people out there, so one can’t just dismiss the movement either.

Wednesday, May 3, 2017

#1829: Carl Kerby

Carl Kerby is one of the founding board members of Answers in Genesis, one of the most ridiculous organizations in existence. Kerby is a representative specimen, and we’ll just give two examples of how his mind seems to work:

Like his fellow AiG members, Kerby believes that more or less all of the Earth’s inhabitants were wiped out some 4,500 years ago during the Biblical flood, and like other young-earth creationists Kerby doesn’t even use this event to explain the extinction of the dinosaurs – Noah brought the dinosaurs on the Ark, all types; anything else would violate the Biblical claim that he did, indeed, bring every kind on the Ark. Of course, as a scientific hypothesis the Ark story has some flaws, but Kerby is a self-styled “creation scientist”, and he’s got them answers. So, to the problem of how to fit two of every animal, for a year, on a boat about 450 feet long, 75 feet wide and 50 feet high – “how did they put the big old dinosaurs on there?” as Kerby poses the question – he goes for the obvious: “Well, I would suggest to you they didn’t take the big old dinosaur — they would have taken the younger ones.” Uh-huh. “My grandson is a whole lot smaller than I am,” elaborated Kerby.

There’s a good report on Kerby’s talk, “Evolution and Pop Culture”, at the 2005 Creation Mega Conference here, which was basically a rant about how references to anything “prehistoric” in movies or TV series is offensive since the Earth is 6000 years old and there is no prehistory. For instance, there was a scene from the movie Ice Age that Kerby didn’t like: A scene from an ice cave showing three animals frozen beside a (living) sloth so that the four are lined up in a row, from a primitive looking creature on the far right to the modern sloth on the left – like an illustration of how the sloth evolved from more primitive ancestors. Enter Kerby: “They [Blue Sky Productions and 20th Century Fox, presumably] were trying to indoctrinate your kids, they were trying to show evolution, but they failed. You know why they failed?” Oh yes, bring it on: “Because they show all four of those animals existing at the same time. That’s not evolution!” Even Ray Comfort would probably not be able to top the inanity of that one. Now, Kerby’s revelation of how Ice Age tried but failed to brainwash kids into believing in evolution would probably render most reasonable people speechless. We’ll grant him that. But yes, one of the premises is that evolution is part of an orchestrated plot to lead children away from Jesus; Hollywood is part of it, but like all Satan-inspired evolutionists Hollywood is doomed to make mistakes that God-fearing people like Kerby are able to spot right away.


Diagnosis: This one might be dim even by young-earth creationist standards, but he’s still a reasonably influential figure – which figures but is nonetheless quite amazing.

Monday, May 1, 2017

#1828: Gary & Hallie Kemper

Who are Gary & Hallie Kemper? Well, at least no one had heard about them until their book Discovering Intelligent Design was touted by the Discovery Institute’s pro-creationism blog. Apparently the book was published by the Institute’s in-house vanity press, the Discovery Institute Press, and it was presented as suitable “supplementary materials” for Louisiana science class, since Louisiana, thanks to the Louisiana Science Education Act, allows distributing creationist tracts in biology classes. The book is described as “the first full curriculum to present the scientific evidence for intelligent design in both cosmology and biology in an easy-to-understand format. The curriculum includes a textbook, a workbook, and a DVD with multimedia video clips that are integrated into the readings.” So, it’s yet another piece of creationist rhetoric aimed at the lay market. We’re still waiting for the science from the Intelligent Design creationists.

The Kempers themselves are apparently homeschoolers – which ought to make their whole marketing campaign look a bit weird – and have no discernible background in science. However, apparently the Discovery Institute’s own “research coordinator” (oh, wee), the infamous Casey Luskin, was involved, too. The publication of the book – which appears to contain all the usual creationist canards – was subsequently ranked by the Discovery Institute as one of their 10 “great triumphs” of 2013. It is telling that triumphs for Intelligent Design creationists don’t mean scientific breakthroughs or anything related to research or discovery, but outreach results, once again demonstrating that the point isn’t to test their theory, but to get it taught in public schools.


Diagnosis: Fundamentalists and non-scientists. Other than that they’re pretty darn obscure, and their impact is probably negligible. Really: WTF is this?