Showing posts with label Minnesota. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Minnesota. Show all posts

Thursday, July 11, 2013

#628: Michael J. Dochniak & Denise H. Dunn


Michael J. Dochniak and Denise H. Dunn are antivaxxers. Indeed, they belong to the fluffy murkiness of the fringes of the already rabidly moronic antivaxx movement. In particular, they are the authors of Vaccine Delivery and Autism (The Latex Connection) (do take a look the comments in that link, in which Dochniak himself shows up; continued here), in which they blame “the latex rubber often used in vaccine packaging and delivery systems,” for what they perceive as an increase in autism rates). The guiding idea is that the dismal failure of previous attempts to link autism to vaccines cannot possibly mean that vaccines are off the hook – the antivaxxers have invested too much in that hypothesis, so instead of rejecting it they need to look for a different kind of connection, and Dochniak’s and Dunn’s attempts are among the desperate results (no, they have no independent evidence for the link).

According to the blurb on the book Dochniak and Dunn are leading experts in the etiology of allergy-induced regressive autism. This is apparently granted them in virtue of having written a book together before called Allergies and Autism, not because they have any real expertise in any related field (Dochniak does point out that he has a publication in the pseudojournal Medical Hypotheses, though, as if that should count for anything). Their work is reviewed here, here, and here, and summed up by commenter Lawrence as “a guess, inside an idea, wrapped in a layer of ‘no evidence.’” Apparently the authors cite Schopenhauer’s infamous (though possibly spuriously attributed), idiotic quote “All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed. Third, it is accepted as being self-evident.” That quote alone should be ample evidence that we are dealing with some serious pseudoscience. And apparently that quote is pretty much all they have to back up their hypothesis.

Diagnosis: Crackpottery, through and through.

Monday, May 20, 2013

#555: Dennis Campbell


Dennis Campbell is a self-proclaimed fundamentalist, and a baptist minister in St Cloud, Minnesota. He is pretty unimportant in the grand scheme of things, one supposes, but his screeds are fairly typically crazy, and sufficiently incoherent to earn him a place in our Encyclopedia. Campbell has warned us (in an ad in a local newspaper) about the Muslim threat to the US, pointing out that ”Moslems seek to influence a nation by immigration, reproduction, education, the government, illegal drugs, and by supporting the gay agenda.” The evidence is, presumably, that gay rights were very high on the agenda of e.g. the Taliban. There’s an interesting follow-up to the ad here, and a good Dennis Campbell resource here. Campbell has also led a prayer in the Minnesota Senate, an event that was the source of some controversy.

Diagnosis: I suppose the indictment in this case really concerns a particular way of thinking: X is my enemy; Y is my enemy; hence X and Y are allies – a variant of the fallacy of the undistributed middle endorsed by a wide range of moronic wingnuts.

Friday, July 22, 2011

#232: Brock Lee

Brock Lee is an unimportant, local creationist in Owatonna, Minnesota, whose sole claim to fame is his sheer idiocy and the fact that his ramblings have been picked up by PZ Myers. He is apparently fond of writing letters to newspapers; for instance see here, where he claims that evolutionary biology (analytically) implies that as long as you are not having sex or are pregnant, you don’t count as a human and hence have no moral status. Because of this analytic connection, evolutionary biology is responsible for teenage pregnancies – teenagers are having sex because they wish to be human. I don’t think there is any point in trying to unravel the various layers of misunderstanding here.


He has also been involved in arranging the Minnesota Creation Science Fair.

Diagnosis: You can’t fake this. Moronic loon (Hovind-sycophant). Probably relatively harmless.

Monday, May 10, 2010

#9: Michele Bachmann


Coming in at #9 we have one of my very favorite loons, the lovely Michele Bachmann.

Bachmann is the United States Representative of Minnesota's 6th congressional district and a member of the Republican Party.

Judging by a number of trustworthy sources and good evidence (mostly the words that come out of her mouth), she may be the single stupidest person alive (perhaps in competition with Steve King, R-Iowa). Staunch supporter of the teabagging party (including all of their contradictory goals, apparently). Good mental compartmentalizer, for she is apparently completely unaffected by (or aware of) cognitive dissonance.
A quickly assembled but unrepresentative sample of the stuff that falls out of her mouth:
http://www.buzzfeed.com/mjs538/the-10-craziest-michele-bachmann-quotes

And a couple of others:

On CO2 emissions:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IAaDVOd2sRQ&feature=player_embedded

On net neutrality:
http://scienceblogs.com/gregladen/2010/05/michele_bachmann_should_shut_u.php

Discussion of her view on the swine flu (and the Democrats’ role in it):
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2009/04/burning_stupid_from_michelle_bachmann.php
And one more informative source of Bachmann quotes:
http://www.michelebachmannsaidwhat.com/


Diagnosis: Complete moron – a living embodiment of Dunning-Kruger. Obviously in possession of power and influence, and probably a large fan group as well; in other words very dangerous.