Thursday, December 4, 2014

#1228: Jacques Vallée


For some truly amazing physics crackpottery I recommend checking out Pentcho Valev (useful introduction here), but Valev is hardly American. Jacques Fabrice Vallée qualifies, though – although French-born, Vallée is at least currently residing in California. Indeed, Vallée is a former astronomer and computer scientist, noted for co-developing the first computerized mapping of Mars for NASA and for his work at SRI International on the network information center for the ARPANET, who at some point turned into a venture capitalist and ufologist. He is, however, notable for rejecting the “extraterrestrial hypothesis” – that is, the idea that UFOs are alien spacecrafts – advocating instead a “multidimensional visitation hypothesis”. Rejecting a stupid claim for an incoherent one, in other words (fans of Vallée include John Weldon and John Ankerberg).

He claims to have experienced rather conclusive evidence for his UFOs, but – of course – the powers that be, to keep their conspiracy going, have tended to destroy it for him. In the late 1960s, however, he decided that there was a link between UFOs, cults, religious movements, demons, angels, ghosts, cryptic sightings, and psychic phenomena (based on “many commonalities” – human psychology being not one of the ones he considered). Speculations about these potential links were detailed in Passport to Magonia: From Folklore to Flying Saucers. He also argued that the UFO reports are simply not consistent with visitations from space, which is true, though Vallée somehow misses the obvious conclusion to draw from that, suggesting instead his interdimensional rubbish. He even claimed that the so-called “Fátima Miracle”, Marian apparitions and possibly the visions of Joseph Smith were … instances of UFOs (so, once again, the obvious explanations elude him). Indeed, his idea that UFOs are associated with some form of non-human consciousness that manipulates space and time and has been active throughout human history, masquerading in various forms to different cultures, does suggest a rather evident religious subtext to his writings – not that far removed from Joseph Smith himself, come to think of it.

Many of his ideas were developed together with his mentor, the infamous late ufologist J. Allen Hynek.

What sometimes seems to lend him a whiff of credibility is his tendency to engage with the craziest and most delusional ideas among ufologists and conspiracy theorists to show how these are wrong, and thereby occasionally managing to come off as a voice of reason in debates – despite the fact that his own views are rarely less crazy than those of his opponents.

Diagnosis: Standard, wild-eyed pseudoscientist and loon.

Wednesday, December 3, 2014

#1227: Glen Urquhart


Many of you probably remember Christine O’Donnell from the 2010 elections, but O’Donnell wasn’t the only wingnut running for office as a Republican in Delaware. Indeed, she may not even have been the most crazy wingnut running for office in Delaware. Meet Glen Urquhart, the Republican Party candidate for the United States House of Representatives election in 2010 in Delaware’s At-large congressional district (and yes, he did lose pretty badly). To give you an idea of who Urquhart is:

“Do you know, where does this phrase ‘separation of church and state’ come from? It was not in Jefferson’s letter to the Danbury Baptists. … The exact phrase ‘separation of Church and State’ came out of Adolph Hitler’s mouth, that’s where it comes from. So the next time your liberal friends talk about the separation of Church and State ask them why they’re Nazis.”

Oh, wheee! Of course, the phrase is pretty explicitly in that latter (Urquhart has of course never bothered to read it). And Hitler pretty explicitly did not believe in such a separation, instead declaring an official established church, the Protestant Reich Church, in Germany.

He later admitted that the phrasing was unfortunate and that he is a strong supporter of the First Amendment, but adding that he also believes the government has gone too far in limiting people’s rights to express their religion by restricting athletes from holding prayers at high school football games, for example, or preventing public schools from teaching alternative theories to evolution such as creationism.

He did secure the endorsement of Mike Huckabee. He gets ours as well: Urquhart is clearly qualified for inclusion in our Encyclopedia.

Diagnosis: Complete moron, and the election results suggest that so is a not insubstantial minority of Delaware’s voters.

The argument about church and state seems to be rather popular among wing nuts; here is Rick Santorum trying it out a couple of days ago.

Tuesday, December 2, 2014

#1226: Fred Upton(?)


The question mark doesn’t really mean that we wonder whether Fred Upton is a loon. He is almost certainly not. But his official views are sufficiently insane that we’ll count him as one. Upton is the U.S. Representative for Michigan’s 6th congressional district, serving since 1987 (he replaced the absolutely incoherently insane Mark Deli Sijander), and Chairman of the Committee on Energy and Commerce. Due to his environmental policies (and his position of power), the LA Times wrote in 2011 that Upton “represents one of the biggest threats to planet Earth on planet Earth,” which seems accurate. As a politician Upton is staunchly committed to climate change denialism, and is determined to prevent any legislation that pays even lip service to environmental problems. He also assigned John Shimkus to chair the Environment and Economy Subcommittee, which is sufficient to qualify Upton as a loon in his own right.

Now, one suspects that Upton position is motivated more by strategy than actual convictions. As late as 2009, he maintained that “climate change is a serious problem that necessitates serious solutions. Everything must be on the table.” In 2010, however, he co-authored a Wall Street Journal editorial saying he was “not convinced” that “carbon is a problem in need of regulation,” urging Congress to overturn Massachusetts v. Environmental Protection Agency, which would be a completely irrational thing to do if you were only “not convinced” (and cared about anything beyond your own short-term goals, of course). He falsely claimed that there is no scientific consensus regarding climate change and was so (deliberately) misinformed regarding “Climategate” that he advocated for congressional hearings.

Not only has he refused to approve any emission limits on greenhouse gases (e.g. here), however; he has also urged lawmakers to reverse the United States Environmental Protection Agency emissions rules. Carbon regulation, according to Upton, “threatens to drive energy prices higher, destroy jobs and hamstring our economic recovery.” (The American automobile industry supports the regulations.)

In 2007 Upton was a co-sponsor of the Energy Independence and Security Act, which among other things mandated phased-in energy efficiency standards for most light bulbs. But in 2010, after Glenn Beck called Upton “all socialist” for supporting the bill, Upton turned around to lead a failed effort to stop Obama from enforcing the new energy standard. Apparently being called “socialist” by Beck is something people of Upton’s kind take very seriously.

On other issues (healthcare, marriage equality, etc.) Upton generally votes strictly in line with recommendations from the religious right.

Diagnosis: One of the most dangerous people alive. Mad dictators of small countries pale in comparison when it comes to having power to truly harm the world and everyone in it. If Upton knows what he is doing (and one suspects he does), he doesn’t care, and I urge anyone to record his name so that you can tell your grandchildren who was responsible for it all. 

#1225: David Tyree


David Tyree is a former football wide receiver who played in the NFL for seven seasons and got famous for his “helmet catch” in the Giants’ final drive in the 2008 Super Bowl. He’s out of NFL now, and currently uses his career to say stupid shit as part of his campaigns against marriage equality. On the day the New York State Assembly approved a same-sex marriage bill, Tyree warned that the bill’s passage would “be the beginning of our country sliding toward … anarchy” (also here), explaining that “[m]arriage is the only relationship that actually mirrors the relationship with God” (which makes absolutely no sense whatsoever) and that it is not justifiable to alter a long-standing institution “because a minority – an influential minority – has … an agenda,” which I don’t think he really means if he thinks about it twice (or once). Furthermore, “[w]e’re doing God an injustice by not making his heart known to our country,” which is, of course, what matters (gay people go home). And methinks quite a few people before Tyree have made what God’s heart (according to them) tells us known.

Diagnosis: No, you don’t necessarily expect insight and acumen from former NFL players discussing issues they know nothing about, but Tyree did open his mouth, and shit did fall out.

Monday, December 1, 2014

#1224: Rocky Twyman


Rocky Twyman is a community organizer, church choir director and public relations consultant from the D.C. suburbs who managed to draw some attention to himself for his profoundly moronic solution to surging gas prices in 2008: prayer. Now, I am sure he is not the only one who has tried that one, but Twyman even went on a tour, staging prayers asking God for cheaper gas in DC (with volunteers from a soup kitchen joining in), at a San Francisco Chevron station, in Oakland (church members) and probably elsewhere. He has also suggested that the economy would recover and everything be perfect in America if President Obama would just emulate Tim Tebow and get on his knees to pray more often; “the answer is simple,” according to Twyman: “Tebow gives God glory for his success and God in turn blesses him.” Twyman has yet had scantt success with getting his insightful economic models into peer-reviewed economy journals (or in lowering gas prices, for that matter). Perhaps it is because he doesn’t discuss the question of whether people may already be praying for wealth and a flourishing economy, with negligible success.

Diagnosis: He doesn’t really understand how it works, and is sufficiently brazen about it that he’s earned himself some media time for his ignorance and idiocy. Probably harmless.